10307 Homes for Sale
Staten Island · ZIP 10307
10307 Homes for Sale
Tottenville. Homes for sale in 10307 right now, what sold here over the last twelve months, and who to call about it.
On the market in 10307
All 10307 listingsKeep up with 10307
Selling? We send you a market report for 10307: what sold, for how much, and what is new. Buying? We send you new listings here as they come up. No account to make.
What sold in 10307
135 one to three family homes sold in 10307 from September 2025 to August 2026, by the city's sales records. The median sale was $990,000.
Latest recorded sales in 10307
- Bentley Lane$728,000 · August 31, 2026
- Aspinwall Street$1,550,000 · August 27, 2026
- Loretto Street$480,000 · August 25, 2026
Source: NYC Department of Finance, sales recorded September 2025 to August 2026. One to three family houses, sales of $10,000 or more, multi-lot sales left out. Medians, not averages. The city records a sale when the deed is filed, one to three months after closing, so the newest weeks join the report once they are complete. Updated monthly.
RE/MAX Edge · 651 Willowbrook Rd, Staten Island, NY 10314 · 718-612-3088. Each office independently owned and operated. Equal Housing Opportunity.
The houses in 10307
Tottenville sells the biggest houses on Staten Island, and the priciest. The median house sale in 10307 last year was $930,000, the highest of any island ZIP, and the median house had 2,229 square feet on a 5,000 square foot lot, also the largest medians on the island. The city recorded 129 such sales here last year.
Two family houses do much of the lifting. They made up 40% of sales, 52 of 129, the highest share on the island, and frame two family was the single most common building class with 48 sales. No other ZIP has that class on top. The median two family had 2,700 square feet and sold for $1,147,500; the median one family had 1,700 square feet and sold for $765,000. No three family house sold here in 2025. Per square foot the picture flips: the median was $441, below seven other ZIPs.
Most of what trades is fairly new. Half the houses sold went up in 1990 or later, and 45 of the houses sold (35%) date from 2000 or later, against 32 from before 1950. After two-story detached houses (37) came attached or semi-detached houses (17) and one-story houses (14).
The spread is wide. A quarter of sales came in under $670,970 and a quarter above $1,250,000. Sprague Avenue and Yetman Avenue shared the top spot from January 2025 on, 15 trades each, with Brehaut Avenue and Arthur Kill Road next at 9. The city filed 128 of last year's 129 sales under Tottenville.
Busiest streets in 10307
- Sprague Avenue15 sales, $1,050,000 median, built 1983, 2,229 sq ft, $556/sq ft
- Yetman Avenue15 sales, $999,000 median, built 1999, 2,200 sq ft, $425/sq ft
- Brehaut Avenue9 sales, $820,000 median, built 1935, 1,937 sq ft, $568/sq ft
- Arthur Kill Road9 sales, $746,500 median, built 1901, 2,142 sq ft, $364/sq ft
- Chelsea Street8 sales, $952,500 median, built 1988, 2,402 sq ft, $462/sq ft
Building classes in 10307
- Frame, 2 units (B2)48 sales, $1,147,500 median, built 2000, 2,700 sq ft, $428/sq ft
- Detached, two story (A1)37 sales, $865,000 median, built 1935, 2,000 sq ft, $426/sq ft
- Attached or semi (A5)17 sales, $555,000 median, built 1990, 1,480 sq ft, $425/sq ft
- One story (A2)14 sales, $723,250 median, built 1962, 1,028 sq ft, $593/sq ft
Source: NYC Department of Finance, 129 house sales recorded in 10307 in 2025; the street list adds 86 recorded January to August 2026. Medians only.
Neighborhoods in 10307
Tottenville. Browse Staten Island neighborhoods or see every ZIP on the map.
Not the right ZIP?
Not the right area? Browse every Staten Island zip code.
Looking across the whole island? See Staten Island homes for sale in every neighborhood, and how buying a house on Staten Island works.
Thinking about selling in Tottenville? Find out what your home is worth, or see what a Staten Island sale actually costs.
Tottenville's only bordering zip code is 10309 (Prince's Bay and Charleston).
New to the area? Read the Tottenville guide, or the Tottenville neighborhood page for commute times and housing types.
Questions about a house in 10307?
Let us know if something catches your eye, we'd be happy to help.
What is your home in 10307 worth?
Start with your address. One of us calls you with the recent sales near you and a market report for your ZIP.