Staten Island neighborhood guide · ZIP 10312

Eltingville, Staten Island: homes and prices

180 one- to three-family homes sold in Eltingville between September 2025 and August 2026, by the city's count. The median sale was $785,000, 4% above the Staten Island median of $755,000.

The homes in Eltingville

Of the homes that sold, 78% were one-family and 22% two-family. The median home was built in 1975, sits on a lot of about 4,000 square feet and has about 1,574 square feet of living space on the city's records.

Lot, block and flood zone move a price more than the neighborhood does, so ask us for the sales closest to a specific address.

Getting around

The Staten Island Railway stops at Eltingville station, with a transfer to the ferry at St. George.

Homes for sale in Eltingville

See homes for sale in 10312, compare prices in every ZIP or read the Staten Island housing market report.

Nearby neighborhoods

• Great Kills: median $756,000
• Annadale: median $992,794
• Huguenot: median $947,500
• Prince's Bay: median $915,000
• Tottenville
• All Staten Island neighborhoods

Source: NYC Department of Finance rolling sales, September 2025 to August 2026. One- to three-family homes unless marked. Medians, not averages. Transfers under $10,000 and multi-lot bulk sales are left out. The city records sales with a delay, so the latest months fill in over time.